• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

KB6NU's Ham Radio Blog

KB6NU's Ham Radio Blog
  • HOME
  • Study Guides
  • Teach a One-Day Tech Class
  • W8SRC Repeater Guide
  • Advertise
  • Hire Me

AMSAT: Time for a Change?

July 19, 2019 By Dan KB6NU 4 Comments

The AMSAT Board of Directors election is underway, and like last year’s ARRL Board elections, there seems to be a bit of a controversy. Bruce Perens, K6BP, is one of the hams that thinks it’s time for a change. He tweets:

Bruce Perens K6BP@BrucePerens
AMSAT Direction Election 2019: It’s Time For Change! I am recommending five candidates who can solve AMSAT’s problems and get the organization going in the right direction. Please see perens.com/static/AMSAT/E… Please re-tweet and pass onto other AMSAT members. @AMSAT

And, on the web page referenced in the URL, he writes:

AMSAT is absolutely vital to continue the role of Amateur Radio in space, one especially important when we’re seeing the start of a challenge to our 2-meter band allocation internationally. But there are problems with AMSAT: It’s now 15 years since AO-40 went SK. We’ve not done anything nearly so ambitious again in North America, while Europe and Africa now have a geostationary 10 GHz transponder for Amateur use. AMSAT’s current management is hogtied and overly fearful of ITAR while the Open Source community, provider of the cryptography in every web browser back when that was under ITAR, has had that problem solved for decades. And AMSAT can’t support itself with the current member dues.

A voice on the other side is Dave Swanson, KG5CCI. In a long series of Tweets, he writes;

…Let’s talk AMSAT BoD election, and let’s keep it simple. You’ve got 2 choices – ORI or the Incumbents.

Some might object to this simplification, but when the candidates tell you to also vote for their preferred candidate, the choice is pretty binary. First Up: ORI. Their simplified platform is this: Build digital birds, Screw the ITAR, and the current AMSAT board is mean.

So, Digital Birds eh? We’ve got digital birds right now. Surprised? That’s because no one uses them. FalconSat-3, NO-44 and NO-84 are all floating around up there right now available to you. They’re amazing pieces of tech, built by awesome engineers, and operators don’t care.

Is that harsh? Probably – but it’s the truth. Like it or not we’re in the appliance age, and the vast majority of ops are appliance operators. If you want to be an experimenter, that’s cool and great – but you’re in the 5%. 5% of the AMSAT fleet should then reflect your desires.

Next – ITAR. I agree, ITAR sucks. In my professional endeavors I’ve experienced first hand how ITAR stifles us. But, it is the law. And while flouting the edges of regulations is great for a small community with nothing to lose, or a small biz not exporting, AMSAT ain’t that.
AMSAT launches satellites on rockets directly controlled by the US Government, Foreign Governments, or giant companies friendly with governments. If you think these folks will continue to give us a ride after adopting a LOL WE R NOW EXEMPT approach to the rules, you’re nuts.

There are genuine issues with ITAR, and they should be hashed out by lawyers. But by electing an AMSAT board calling for disregarding ITAR based on their experience on the ground, the chances of us putting stuff in space drops dramatically. The game sucks, but we have to play it.

Finally, the “mean” issue. Not sure what I can say here other than laugh. People aren’t always going to get along, that’s what makes us, us. Block them on twitter, ignore their email – whatever, it has nothing to do with the primary goal of AMSAT – keeping amateur radio in space.

So, with this in mind as an operator, The ORI approved slate of candidates directly threatens my ability to keep making contacts on the Satellites. Their desire make the birds beep-boop only, pick a fight with our government sponsors, and get even over perceived slights is wrong.

Alternatively, the Incumbent Board Members of @glasbrenner @PRStoetzer and @n0jy have launched 4 birds in 5 years, with another going up soon. They’ve got a plan for an entire next generation of sats, have kept the fleet usable by everyone, and followed the law to the letter.

Do I have problems with things like the Website or Office Expenses? Yea. Should we be doing more to build bigger better birds? Absolutely. I’ve got a whole list of things I’d like to see @AMSAT change – and I hope with all the publicity around this election some stuff will.

All this said, those issues pale in comparison to the primary goal of AMSAT. At the end of the day, I just want to make some contacts – nothing else really matters. The incumbent candidates have proven they can help me do that. The ORI group hasn’t, and doesn’t appear to want to.

I plan to vote for @glasbrenner @PRStoetzer & @n0jy and I hope you in the operator community will join me. Cause that’s how we’ll keep Amateur Radio in Space. If you disagree, well, then go write your own tweet storm, cause one is enough for me. 73.

Not being a satellite operator, I hadn’t really been keeping up on this. You can find all of the director candidates’ statements on the AMSAT website.

If you have any thoughts, I’d love to hear from you. Please comment below.

Related posts:

  1. Support these candidates if you want change on the ARRL board
  2. Let’s Change the Term “Amateur Radio”
  3. AMSAT runs on your donations
  4. From my Twitter feed: New AMSAT stuff, using KiCAD, find HF beacons

Filed Under: Satellites Tagged With: AMSAT

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jim Myers says

    July 20, 2019 at 9:55 am

    KG5CCI has to be the most technologically ignorant person I’ve herd of in quite some time. He’s obviously 100% against open source, has literally no clue what ORI is about, no clue what the Bureau of Industry and Security is about, or how they ELIMINATED the issue with ITAR long ago.

    Should anyone be giving any credence to someone that has not progressed technologically in the past 50 years or do?

    I wonder which closed-source companies he’s being propped up by?

    Reply
  2. Dave Swanson says

    July 20, 2019 at 11:56 am

    Hi Jim,

    My first few tweets weren’t included in this post, but I laid out my credentials well. In short, I work for a company that embraces open source software, I did my graduate research on satellites (including Phase IV) and I’m a business partner in a company that possesses an ITAR waiver due to the manufacturing of items classified as ‘Munitions’. I understand modern technology and the legalities around it quite well. You can’t just declare a machine like a satellite be to ‘open source’ and expect to do business in the orbital launch sector. Software is one thing, physical assets are a complete different thing. And don’t just take my word for it, take the word of professional attorneys that AMSAT hired and came to the same conclusion regarding ITAR that I did.

    Now, if you have any other salient points I’m happy to discuss them. But if your only retort to my comments will be attacks that I haven’t progressed in 50 years, I’m ignorant, against open source, and wonder who I’m being propped up by, then I’ll have take my 37 year old self away from my Fedora laptop here in the workshop of my small business, and ignore your drivel.

    73!

    Dave, KG5CCI

    Reply
  3. Armando Mercado N8IGJ says

    July 14, 2020 at 11:12 am

    Interesting reading this in July 2020. AMSAT is tearing itself apart. So the new crowd wants a broadband microwave GEO constellation to cover the world, and transparency. The GEO sat thing isn’t going to happen unless somebody comes up with millions of $$$. Simple fact.

    Reply
    • Dan KB6NU says

      July 14, 2020 at 11:33 am

      You’re right about the money, but it will never happen unless they start working towards it. I’ve been meaning to write more about what’s going on with AMSAT, but I just don’t know enough without doing a lot more research.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

No Nonsense Technician Class License Study Guide (for tests given between July 2026 and June 2030)

New No Nonsense Technican Class Study Guide now available!

The 2026 version of my Tech Class study guide is now available, and as always, the PDF version is FREE!. The ePub version costs $11.97, and a Kindle version and paperback version will be available on Amazon shortly.

Click here to get all of my "No Nonsense" study guides.

Also available: The CW Geek's Guide to Having Fun with Morse Code

W5SWL.Com
Retevis Ailunce H1 DMR Radio
DXpander: Cobweb antennas, Laser Cutting

You’ve got mail!

Enter your email address below and get an email every time I publish a new post.

Email


I frequently teach classes to help newcomers get their licenses. The next class will take place on Saturday, October 10, 2026 on the University of Michigan campus. Click here for more information.

If you can't make the class, subscribe to the mailing list to be notified of when the next class will be held.

You can always download my free study guide, and if you have any questions about the classes, or amateur radio in general, please feel free to email me directly.

Support KB6NU.Com

Donate $7.30 and get two of these cool stickers. Measuring 4.25-in. W by 2.75-in. H, it's perfect for your car, your shack, or wherever!

Contact me

If you have a question or comment about one of my blog posts, or a question about any of the material in my study guides, or just a question about ham radio in general, you can email me at [email protected].

Blogs You Should Also Read

  • AE5X: A CW-centric blog from Kingswood, Texas
  • K0LWC Blog
  • LA3ZA Ham Radio Blog
  • Little Radios, Big Fun – WB3GCK
  • Mr. Vacuum Tube's Blog
  • Radio Artisan – K3NG
  • The K0NR Weblog
  • VE3WDM's QRP Ham Radio Blog
  • W2LJ’s Blog

Ham Radio Websites

  • Dashtoons – The Hammin' Comedy by Jeff K1NSS

Podcasts

  • ICQ Podcast
  • Linux in the Ham Schack
  • No Nonsense Amateur Radio Podcast
  • Resonant Frequency Amateur Radio Podcast

Recent Comments

  • Mir Labs on Ten Steps to Mastering Morse Code
  • Skip K4EAK on Is the ARRL finally feeling the heat?
  • Victor on 468: Ham Radio’s Magic Number
  • Goody K3NG on Not1MM now working on my Linux box!
  • Mir Labs on JA1NUT: Two Issues in Morse Code Learning

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Footer

Copyright © 2026 Daniel M. Romanchik, KB6NU · Log in